I think McPake deserves a chance at this league without the insane injury list we had this season and with the strengthened squad we have compared to the way we started.
This is assuming we keep Edwards, Kane, MFW, MWH of course, which obviously isn't certain, but if we did, and we can keep more people fit than we did for most of 23/24, then I think we'd be in a better place this time next year than we are now.
But, I really think we need to move away from 5 at the back. Go with 4-4-2, and we have this sort of depth:
GK: Mehmet, Little/Whoever
RB: MWH, Comrie, Fisher (I think?)
CBx2: Bene, MFW, Otoo, Fisher, Breen
LB: Edwards, ummm... Otoo maybe? Or Breen?
RM: KRH, MOH
CMx2: Todd, Otoo, Hamilton, Moffat, Chalmers, Allan
LM: Todd, ummm... Allan maybe?
ST: Kane, Jak, Wighton, McCann, Sutherland
Obviously that's over-simplistic (and I've probably forgotten some players), but I do think there's a decent team to be had in there, if we could add a left sided player or two. A team good enough to make the playoffs next time, which should be our minimal goal (although obviously we should be trying for the title).
Scoring goals might still be an issue, but I think we'd have more width, and would be making more and better chances than this year.